Super Smash Bros. Ultimate brings together every single fighter from the series’ history, plus a handful of new contenders. But even with that massive roster, the developers aren’t slowing down. During a Nintendo Direct, director Masahiro Sakurai confirmed that five DLC characters would be coming to the game. That’s on top of Piranha Plant, a free addition to those who buy the game digitally or register their copy by January 31, 2019.

We already know the first of the five DLC characters: Joker from Persona 5. With such a left-field choice, all bets are seemingly off for who the remaining DLC fighters could be. Notably, each one will also bring a new stage and music track to the game.

We racked our brains and made a wishlist of four additional characters we’d like to see join the fight. Some seem like safe bets, while others are pretty radical choices. Check out the video above, and let us know which characters you’d like to see join the roster in the comments below!

In other Smash Bros. news, the game’s first weekly event kicks off Thursday, December 13. It will focus on characters who wear glasses, and their respective Spirits will appear more frequently on the Spirit Board.